Duck, Duck, Goose...A Log Cabin in the Middle of Detroit

I first learned of the anachronistic log cabin known as the James Smith House several years ago by chancing across one of Ren Farley's entries at detroit1701.org. Naturally I had to go see this cartographical anomaly for myself. I was always aware of the c.1885 log cabin in Palmer Park (which I also explored in another post), but this was something entirely different—it was not a fanciful plaything built for a rich senator, this was a real honest-to-god Michigan frontier log cabin from the early 1800s. And it was still standing smack in the middle of Detroit's inner city near Rosa Parks & Davison, completely forgotten by basically everyone except the neighbors, hiding behind its deceptive veneer of modern vinyl siding:

Next to all the tall two-story houses on Clements Street the Smith House is comparatively tiny, and sits crooked to all of its neighbors. Note also its small windows and stuccoed stone chimney. Behind that unsuspecting vinyl siding is a wall hewn of stout logs that were cut down with an axe when Detroit was still a tiny village five miles to the south of here.

According to the tiny State of Michigan historical plaque over the porch, this house was built between 1820 and 1850—which makes it one of the oldest standing structures left in the city—if not the oldest. The current title of Detroit's oldest remaining structure rests with the Charles C. Trowbridge House at 1380 East Jefferson, which was built in 1826.

A look at the relevant Sanborn map corroborates the fact that the 1920s neighborhood grid was simply platted right over the existing Smith House:

Click for full size.

The Smith House clearly does not align with those modern leylines, and instead remains oriented to a much older meridian, rebelliously bucking the uniform ranks of its surrounding 1920s brethren. Unfortunately Sanborn maps don't go back far enough to show when the house was built—they were first started in 1867. I imagine that the old Wayne County plat maps show when the James Smith farm appeared on tax rolls, which might be a good way to figure out the house's approximate age, aside from guesses based on the type of materials it's made out of. Another route might be to check through the city directories at the Burton Historical Library, which go back to the 1840s.

When James Smith built this house it was a farm on the edge of the wilderness, but who knows how many modifications and modernizations were done to it over the decades since then. When this neighborhood was developed, the house was already 100 years old. The fact that it is still standing here intact at all and wasn't torn down to build a bigger house (or torched on Devil's Night) is a minor miracle. This probably implies that when the surrounding houses were built up, the Smith House was still occupied by an owner who had no intention of leaving—perhaps a living descendent of the Smith family itself. The house was listed in the Michigan Registry of Historic Sites in July, 1990.

Image via Google Streetview.

I became even more excited when I realized that the house was vacant and possibly for sale in 2013, but alas my dreams of log cabin ownership did not come to fruition. The Smith House is located in what would be considered by most historic home buyers as an "undesirable neighborhood," which probably explains why it sits empty and in a state of neglect. Not to mention there are few people willing to live in a place this small. But I bet there's already someone out there who's plotting to uproot it and move it to Midtown where it can become a frontier-themed artisanal coffee bar that no one can afford.

In this view from down the street it almost looked like the Smith House was haphazardly dropped here by a tornado, possibly with some stripe-stockinged Wicked Witch legs protruding from beneath it:

Image via Google Streetview.

Google Books surprised me when I turned up this historic (though low-resolution) photo of the Smith House from a c.1893 book entitled, Picturesque Detroit and Environs: 1,000 Illustrations:

Image via Google Books

The caption says, "THE OLD JAMES SMITH LOG HOUSE—TWELFTH STREET," and the viewpoint of the photo appears to be looking west. More importantly it seems to show a lean-to addition to the house that no longer exists, and another perhaps farm-related structure on the right edge of the frame. The dirt path running through the center of the photo follows the general line of what would later become Clements Street. A c.1904 map I have of Detroit shows this area to still be totally undeveloped...12th Street (Rosa Parks Blvd.) passes nearby, but it becomes nothing more than a lonely country road once it goes north of Joy Road.

The following four images come from the Detroit Historical Society collection, and are all dated c.1977 for some reason:

Image from detroithistorical.org 

Image from detroithistorical.org

Image from detroithistorical.org

Image from detroithistorical.org

Update: As of November 2015 the house was owned by the Detroit Land Bank Authority and has been placed on their "no-demolish" list, thanks to the foresight of some preservation-minded activists. Also, as of February 2016 an old friend of mine has recently written his own story about this house: freep.com/story/john-carlisle/2016/02/27/detroit-oldest-cabin-hidden-in-neighborhood
For more discussion on the house, go here: detroityes.com/mb/showthread.php?21228-Detroit-s-Oldest-Cabin-Lies-Hidden-in-a-Neighborhood

Update: As of November 2018, the house has been listed for sale, along with its neighbor:
https://detroit.curbed.com/2018/12/7/18131185/detroits-oldest-house-for-sale-james-smith-log-cabin

Update: As of February 2019, another log cabin house was discovered at 2038 Halleck Street. Unfortunately the Land Bank tore it down despite efforts from local preservationists:
https://www.detroitnews.com/story/news/local/detroit-city/2019/03/11/log-cabin-detroit-land-bank-hamtramck


References:
Sanborn Maps of Detroit Volume 14, Sheet 61 (1925)
http://detroit1701.org/SmithFarm.htm
http://detroit1701.org/Trowbridge_Hist.htm
Picturesque Detroit and Environs: 1,000 Illustrations, edited by Charles Forbes Warner, p. 26
http://detroithistorical.pastperfectonline.com/photo/8D1EDFC6-9215-44E6-BD7A-653468233432
http://detroithistorical.pastperfectonline.com/photo/92A443DE-E7D6-4F29-B82B-940321297983
http://detroithistorical.pastperfectonline.com/photo/C7269394-F937-4A7B-938B-986178051868
http://detroithistorical.pastperfectonline.com/photo/B5F0A782-15ED-4D09-9159-393935178537
https://www.detroitnews.com/story/news/local/detroit-city/2019/03/11/log-cabin-detroit-land-bank-hamtramck